RSS

New! Lizzie Borden Chat Page on Facebook

ajbsofa

Check this out.  Lively discussion on the photo of Andrew Borden on the sofa and preliminary autopsy.  Lizzie Andrew Borden Chat Page on Facebook.

smashedAJB

 

And while we’re at it:   WHO WORE IT BEST?

ricciaxeChristina Ricci

Candy_Montgomery_ax_murdererCandace Montgomery

lizaxe                                                      Elizabeth Montgomery

 

Adapting JFK and Lizzie Borden – Quality vs. Schlock

Franco

I’m excited about this adaptation of Stephen King’s “11/22/63″  novel which I read last summer.  Adapted from a very creative, imaginative and riveting novel on the President Kennedy assassination typical, of King’s superlative writing, this 9 part mini series  (no premiere date yet set) should also prove to be inventive, creative, well produced, and directed (Bridget Carpenter)..  And the acting chops of James Franco makes it even more exciting to me.  So far this adaptation has all the ear marks of being of high quality.

Here we have a fictionalized account of a real life historical event that was front page news the world over.  An event so catastrophic to our country and had significant impacts the world over.  We all knew or now know of John F. Kennedy, his family, his background. Television gave us a visual play by play of his assassination.  Taking this historical event and adapting it onto a relatively new format shown on Hulu, we anticipate the liberties that will be taken but don’t much mind because the adapted plot is already cleverly contrived and promises to be well executed and produced.

Christina_Ricci_Lizzie_Borden_axe

With the “Lizzie Borden Chronlcles” we already have more than just a glimpse of what to expect from this “fictionalized”  8-part mini-series of what “could have” happened to Lizzie post Trial premiering in April.  We already know the manner in which Lizzie is presented – young, psychotic, over-sexed…..  Oh well.   Most of what constitutes this mess could be forgiven if it were a solid, quality piece of television drama.  But it is not.  Nor will it be.  Adaptation of the basic story already sold out artistic excellence for ratings.

Adapted stories, i.e., adaptations of real life events and people from history or contemporary times is as old as the early performances at the Globe Theater in Queen Elizabeth the First’s  time.  But in judging the quality of such productions we must factor in the writing, the directing, the acting – the entire production.  What separates a “good adaptation” from schlock is the end product of all these things.

CRITICIZING WHAT IS DEEMED TO BE SCHLOCK IS LESS ABOUT THE DEVIATION OR ABSENCE OF FACT THAN IT IS ABOUT A POORLY PRODUCED – ON ALL LEVELS – ADAPTATION OF AN HISTORIC EVENT OR PERSON(S).  

And any past community college drama teacher (yes, you, Stefani Koorey) – should know that.  Then again, perhaps Ms. Koorey didn’t  teach her students to differentiate between the two.

As to her assertion that it will make people want to read more about Lizzie Borden – I can only say:  “Abraham Lincoln – Vampire Hunter” hasn’t exactly caused a rush of tourists to Gettysburg nor increased interest in our 16th President.

“Lizzie Borden Had An Axe” was a schlock production giving us every reason to believe (not to mention the previews, writer, director and producers) that the new adaptation,  “The Lizzie Borden Chronicles” will be as well. By contrast, there’s a reason why The Walking Dead is the #1 TV show in the country.

Judging from the cast, director, writer, and  producers of “11-22-63″, we can be much more hopeful.

 
2 Comments

Posted by on February 13, 2015 in Uncategorized

 

Tags: , , , , ,

Lizzie Borden Connection: The Cotton Web: Barnabas Olney & M.C.D. Borden – Fiction Based on Fact?

(Recycled post)

It’s a brand new year, so I’ve changed up my WordPress theme.  I may change it again.   :)

(Originally posted on 2/26/2008)

Too lazy to create something new just yet so here’s a recycled post.

No, it’s not Elizabeth Taylor in this 1960 jacket cover designed by Ray Pollak, but it could have been since Liz looked like that in 1960. Rather the cover depicts the main character, Kitty McCarran, in Barbara Hunt’s 1958, 350 page fictional story centered in Fall River and based on historical fact. It’s basically the story of a poor, 20 year old Irish immigrant beauty who arrives on the steamship Priscilla the day before Christmas in 1901, to stay with relatives.

From the book jacket: “Barnabas Olney, the leading mill owner in Fall River, was a man of deep compassion with a rigid New England conscience that set him apart from the turbulent, grasping commercial world around him. But to Olney’s son, Lucian, sensual and cushioned from the realities of life by his father’s wealth and position, nothing mattered except money and his own pleasure. It was Lucian that Kitty determined to marry. Before long, she discovered that even her iron will was powerless against a code that regarded as unthinkable marriage between an Irish immigrant mill worker and the aristocratic son of a leading mill owning family.”

There are few fiction books on Fall River or the Lizzie Borden case that I would recommend, but I recommend this one. The Cotton Web is a good read because of its basis in fact and the sharp clarity with which Barbara contrasts the lives and lifestyles of these two classes. Anyone who has ever visited Fall River and gazed upon those 5-story granite or red brick mills with their towering chimineys and bell towers, or driven down Main Street, or seen the tenement houses and imagined the weary walk back from a 12 hour work day, cannot help but to relate to the accurate descriptions she so beautifully pens within its pages.

Miss Hunt goes to the heart of the difference between the mill owners/managers and the mill workers in the second and third paragraphs below.

I can’t help but be intrigued by Miss Hunt’s notation preceding the Contents page of her book: “Although the historical events used as the background of this novel are accurate and true, the characters, the plot, and the cotton mills principally concerned in the story are all fictitious. I’m deeply indebted to my Fall River friends for their long memories, their books which they lent me so freely, and their patience in answering my many questions.”

I find it intriguing because of the similarity to a true life scandal involving Matthew Chaloner Durfee Borden’s third son, Matthew S. Borden whose life ended tragically, and the fictional Barnabas Olney’s son Lucian, whose life ended…..well, you’ll have to read the book. But it occurred to me in reading that notation that perhaps Miss Hunt’s “friends”, with their long memories, told her the true story of another of Fall River’s private disgraces concerning a Borden.

MCD Borden was born July 18, 1842 in Fall River. He had one of the best pedigree’s of all Bordens. A contemporary of Andrew Borden (Lizzie’s father), MCD was the 6th of 7 children born to Colonel Richard Borden (1785-1874) and Abby W. Durfee. He married Harriet M. Durfee in 1865 and they had 7 children, including 3 sons. MCD was the driving force that set Fall River back on a path of upward expansion. He represented the Borden-Durfee interests in New York. With the Braytons he founded the BMC Durfee Trust Company, converted the Iron Works completely to textiles and built the largest textile corporation in the United States. He was a compassionate man regarding his employees and his mills were not struck by the labor unions when his relatives’ mills were. He died May 27, 1912 in Rumson, Monmouth, New Jersey.

But he had his own scandal. His son, Matthew, had fallen in love with the daughter of a Jewish tailor, one Mildred Negbauer. Not having the kind of pedigree for a Borden to marry into, this incurred MCD’s wrath. It turned into a scandal when it was found out the impetuous Matthew had actually secretly married the “low class” Mildred. MCD stepped in and persuaded her to accept payment to have the marriage dissolved. She accepted the payment, and the young Matthew went on to graduate from his father’s alma mater, Yale University. Matthew then went on to medical school and became a doctor. However, after which, he and Mildred renewed their torrid romance. About 4 years later, they re-wed, again without his father’s blessings and the angered MCD Borden actually disinherited this youngest son. In fact, it was reported that Matthew asccepted a million dollars not to contest his father’s will. In the summer of 1914, Dr. Matthew S. Borden, while driving in Cape May County, New Jersey, was racing a locomotive to a grade crossing. The train won. Matthew lost his life, taking the lives of three others with him.

So, did the parallels in The Cotton Web find some inspiration from the tragic true life events? Was MCD Borden Barbara Hunt’s inspiration for the character of Barnabas Olney? Were some of the characteristics and experiences of Lucian Olney meant to be partially based on Matthew S. Borden? Maybe. Maybe not. But the similarities are striking.

Sources:

Rumson, Shaping a Superlative Suburb (The Making of America Series), Randall Gabrielan, Arcadia Press, p41.

The Durfee-Borden Connection, Men in Business, Robert K. Lamb essay, edited by William Miller.

 

Tags: , , , ,

Is the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast Haunted?

Originally posted on Tattered Fabric: Fall River's Lizzie Borden:

The explosion of interest in the paranormal in today’s society has resulted in several “ghost hunting” investigative t.v. shows, cottage industry “entertainment mediums” who proliferate the ‘net with their blogs and websites, bona fide mediums and psychics whose best-sellers help launch their own talk shows, increase manufacture and sales of evp recording devices, increase demand for Ghost Hunter University applicants, and hundreds of bookings at the Lizzie Borden Bed and Breakfast. Why is this? Why now at this time, post 9-11 in this new millenium? What is it in our culture, our society, that draws people from all professions, and all religious and educational backgrounds? I don’t know, but I do know that it’s a phenomena which continues to grow as well as those who would capitalize from it. It’s the American way.

The Lizzie Borden house from the north looking south from the space the Churchill house used to…

View original 1,106 more words

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on January 31, 2015 in Uncategorized

 

To Haunt or Not to Haunt – The Lizzie Borden B&B

(Originally posted October 6, 2011 – See related posts at bottom).

The reputation of the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast Museum being haunted has escalated over the years due to its exposure from the many television  paranormal “entertainment” shows.  Unlike the made-for-t.v.documentaries that focus on Lizzie herself, the town of Fall River, her sister Emma and Uncle John, these ghostly presentations are served up in abundance.

Spin-off and copy cat shows recycle, repackage and replicate attempting to satisfy the masses who can’t seem to get enough.  The popular Ghost Hunters and Ghost Adventures are only two of the many paranormal/investigative sub genre.  But let us not forget these programs are pure theater  They ARE entertainment.  They ARE produced, programmed and broadcast by companies that are in business – and the purpose of ANY business is to make a profit. Some productions are better than others, but most are like Howdy Doody on steroids.

Before the crush of competitive paranormal and ghost hunting shows there were the lesser known features.  This early one, featuring my long time friend Martha McGinn is one I particularly like because it has many of the original employees of the B&B.  Eleanor Thibault, who tells of the “smoke” holds the distinction of having the record for the longest, continuous employee.  She is the wife of Ed Thibault who has been featured in so many documentaries playing Andrew Borden.

So now we have autumn and the Halloween season upon us.  Expect to see repackaged repeats of the haunted Lizzie Borden House.  Yech.  Is it haunted?  I don’t think so.  But if you sell it, they will come.  And they have; both production companies and those seeking the paranormal experience.

Oh, Lizzie.  You never really liked that house, but you wouldn’t believe it now.

Happy Halloween, darlin’.  And try not to let those treading footfalls around your headstone disturb you too much.  Pretend it’s Princess Summerfallwinterspring come to play Magda.  Or maybe it’s just Clarabell the Clown – wearing a hockey mask.

About these ads

Occasionally, some of your visitors may see an advertisement here.

Tell me more | Dismiss this message

Edit

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

 

Christina Ricci’s Lizzie Borden Marries Abraham Lincoln – Vampire Hunter

aa

If you enjoyed last January’s (2014) showing of “Lizzie Borden Had an Axe” on the Lifetime Movie Channel, did (do) you also like the series Abraham Lincoln, Vampire Hunter?  (The latter was developed from the 2010 film  produced by Tim Burton)  Did the ALVH series make you want to –

Visit the Lincoln monument and tour Washington, DC?

Study the Civil War?

Tour Gettysburg?

Visit Springfield, Mass.?

Did you feel compelled to order some biographies on Abraham Lincoln?

Rush out to Redbox or sign up with Netflix and order some documentaries or films on Abraham Lincoln?

No?   Didn’t think so.

If you enjoyed Christina Ricci in the Lifetime Movie Channel’s version of Lizzie Borden and looking forward to her coming back as a serial killer with unleashed sexual lust, do you think it will make you want to –

Visit Fall River, MA?

Tour the Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast/Museum where the actual murders of 1892 took place?

Book a room for an overnight stay at the LBB&B?

Explore the Fall River Historical Society and Oak Grove Cemetery?

Travel to Fall River and gaze upon “Maplecroft”, the real house she lived in post Trial?

Rent documentaries on the Borden case?

Purchase or rent books written on the Borden case?

Do some genealogical research on the Borden family?

Google “Lizzie Borden” for sites that deal with facts of the case?

No?  Didn’t think so.

I don’t think a single one of 8 upcoming episodes of the “Lizzie Borden Chronicles” will inspire or motivate the viewers to any of the above.  I think the series will attract those who like their television dramas sexy, bloody, and requiring a minimal amount of cerebral effort.  Now, that’s not to say it won’t have entertainment value and draw a big audience.  On the contrary.  I’m just saying it won’t bear any resemblance to the real Lizzie Borden or anything about what she did and what happened to her post Trial.   The Network and producers (including the executive producer, Ms. Ricci, who has a stake in the ratings and not just a salary)  have already verified this by stating it is all fiction not based on fact.  To this I say, then why pimp out the name “Lizzie Borden”?  Could it be just for ratings?

Clearly, the Network sold the series by capitalizing on the 4.4 million viewers from last January, knowing their odds where so much better than to come up with the same story-line with a title like, oh, say “The Lizzie Schwartz Chronicles”   That would have been a  much harder pitch.

I like what Richard Behrens, author of the fictional but highly entertaining and well written, Lizzie Borden, Girl Detective  had to say on Stefani Koorey’s Facebook page about the Christina Ricci version of Lizzie Borden:

behrens

Richard BehrensStef, its great you loved the movie. I can definitely see how someone would like it and I’ve watched it about three times so far I’m just not there with you. Although I admire a few things about it, I just don’t like it. I thought it was a misfire for many reasons. I’m not objecting because of any historical inaccuracies (I loved the off-Broadway musical which left historical accuracy behind in the dust). I do feel that it would have taken very little to patch up some of the inaccuracies, and their failure to do says a lot about their desitre to have another teen slasher film rather than make a film about Lizzie Borden. The film seems highly targeted to a specific type of audience, those who devour Jane Austen Zombie Slashing mash-ups in which the Bennett Sisters court Mr. Darcy while occassionally cracking open zombie skulls with axes. And they turned Lizzie Borden into a teenager (by choosing an acress who looks about 15 years old) rather than Montgomery who portrayed her as a woman. It was lush, slick, atmospheric and had a few good acting performances, but I thought Ricci was horrible and the absolutely worst actress for the role. I would have preferred a strong performance by a better actress. As for the upcoming TV series, I think my historical accuracy hat must prevail: it’s one thing to depict Lizzie killing her father and step-mother (she may have in real life), but depictiong her as a serial killer, that’s as dumb as depicting her a girl detective…uh…hmm. No comment.”

The above was in response to her blog post HERE.

There was a time when Stefani would have blasted to high heavens the inaccuracy of that January production.  However, I think it more than just a bit transparent she is playing it safe in deliberately not maligning – but rather praising – the production in hopes her self-declared “talking head” celebrity on the case will garner her future connections for on-screen time as a case scholar or credited consultant.  Give it a rest, Stef, ain’t gonna happen.

A production company that doesn’t even bother to shoot in the State of Massachusetts, incorporate photographs or depict what the house at 92 Second Street actually looks like, let alone utilize the expertise of the curators or the archives of the Fall River Historical Society in its first production “based on the real Lizzie Borden”  is sure as hell not going to seek out “talking heads” on the subsequent 8 episodes advertised as “fiction”.

If there’s a marriage between the Lizzie Borden Chronicles and Abraham Lincoln, Vampire Hunter any offspring will surely be maniacal, blood-sucking, size 2 teenagers with axes for hands, pansy broaches for eyes and a passion that all people are created equal – especially programming execs on the Lifetime Movie Channel.  ;)

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on January 27, 2015 in Uncategorized

 

Lizzie Borden Chronicles – “History Be Damned”

lizzie-borden-1-14-1

When the Lifetime Movie Channel aired “Lizzie Borden Took an Axe” they had no idea the ratings would come in at 4.4 million viewers.  That’s more than 3 times the viewership usually received on their formulated stories.  Naturally, this sent the suits scurrying to turn it into a series which was going to be called “The Fall River Chronicles.”

I commented at the time there was so much more to Fall River’s history than just the Lizzie Borden story and it would be wonderful if they addressed that history, i.e, the mills and mill workers down in the slums contrasted by the mill owners, bankers and the like residing up on “the Hill”.  A history rich in stories of the founding families who, for nearly 200 years, controlled Fall River and its “golden era” (the 1870’s) when cotton was King and Fall River was the Kingdom. But nooooooooooo.  They opted to appeal to the prurient interests of knuckle-draggers as well as the mass audience that loves their true crime with lots of blood and gore.  Alas, ratings equal sponsors and sponsors equal money and as with all things, it’s always about the money.

facesThe collage above illustrates all the principle characters in the Borden case.  They all have intriguing stories in and of themselves.  Indeed, there are so many story lines to be told for each of those principles that it would could fill 8 seasons of programming let alone 8 episodes.  However, the way in which the “Lizzie Borden Chronicles” is being dramatized  by Lifetime they might as well call it the “Lizzie Schwartz Chronicles”.  There will barely be a thread of resemblance to Lizzie herself in the way she looked and lived, let alone the people who were a part of her life.  Instead, we shall see a psychopathic serial killer with wanton sexual desires played out against a threadbare tapestry of Victorian customs and costumes.  Arrggghh.

Lifetime has committed to 8 episodes now and admits this series is not fact-based.  Click HERE    For some short videos neatly assembled and with their playing time, and with a few interviews I had not seen before, Click Lizzie Borden’s Christina Ricci Talks ‘Satisfying,’ Expanded Round”  on this same page.

Also, IMDB critic review already sees it for what it is – and “history be damned”.

I supposed there are many out there who knew from the get-go (as I did) that this series was going to be (and will be) crap.  Don’t look for anything remotely like the truth or historical accuracy here.  Accept it as your usual low brow television programming.

“Same World, Different Beast”

Read the rest of this entry »

 
3 Comments

Posted by on January 15, 2015 in Theatre & Film, TV

 
 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 207 other followers